St. George’s is very proud of its 325-year history and legacy. The bullet-point history below is a work in progress and is updated as more information is discovered and added. There have been three parish histories, 1841, 1881, and 1932 (noted below), but the last 90 years of the parish history is less complete.
Historical and genealogical research
St. George’s early records, e.g., vestry minutes, marriages, baptisms, and burials, were digitalized in 2021 and are available at Long Island University’s Palmer School of Library and Information Science. Click here. Please note that this is not a searchable database but scans of the original documents.
Some of St. George’s early records have been transcribed and are available online. The information on these websites is largely based on the transcriptions published in the third parish history (1932, see below) and not directly from original documents. These projects were not sponsored by St. George’s but undertaken by individuals and other historical organizations.
Baptisms:
https://longislandgenealogy.com/StGeorge/1792-1845.htm
Baptisms performed at St George's Church, Hempstead, Long Island, NY
St. George's Parish Baptism Records, Hempstead Nassau County New York
Marriages:
St George's Church - Records Index
Recently, a joint endeavor between Ancestry.com and the Episcopal Diocese of Long Island has allowed St. George’s sacramental registers to be digitalized through approximately 1950. That link will be added when it becomes available. Please check back.
St. George’s historic graveyard is nearly as old as the parish itself. A map of St. George’s graveyard, short biographies of some of the well-known people, and a complete database of those buried here is available at: Historic St. George Cemetery – This work was largely undertaken by the Rock Hall Museum and their Director Amy Vacchio. St. George’s is very grateful for their outstanding work. Visit the Rock Hall Museum website here.
Other historical, archival, and genealogical inquiries may be sent to Reine Bethany, the Parish Historian and Archivist, at reinebethany@gmail.com or the Rector, Fr. Sean Wallace, at Fr.SeanWallace@gmail.com

TIMELINE OF THE HISTORY OF ST. GEORGE’S CHURCH
(updated, November 6, 2026)
The Groundwork is Laid, 1643–1695
1643 The Town of Hempstead is founded by Dutch and English immigrants, mostly from dissenting religious sects such as Presbyterians and Independents. Using public funds, the Town provides for a Dissenting minister; however, it proves difficult to retain clergy in the position, and there are several extended periods over the next 50 years during which the office is vacant. The first minister on record is John Moore in 1651.
1657 Missionaries from the Society for Friends (Quakers) arrive in the area and establish several communities. Over time, they draw “many away from the church,” in part by railing against the use of public funds for “hireling priests.”
1648 The first meeting house is built by the Town near Burley Pond. It is a multi-purpose building, serving the Town for meetings and business on weekdays and as a church on Sundays. The historical tablets in the nave of St. George’s consider this the “first church building.”
1673 A larger meeting house is built by the Town on the current church grounds, slightly west of the current church building, on the site now occupied by Regan Hall (see 1958 below). The historical tablets in the nave of St. George’s consider this the “second church building.” It will serve as the church for St. George’s from its founding in 1702 (see below) to 1735.
1674 After years of conflict, the Dutch permanently cede New York to England.
1679 Quakers are legally forbidden to preach publicly, but the damage is done and the Dissenting church in Hempstead enters a period of decline.
1682 In an effort to retain a minister, a parsonage is built with public funds on the site of the current rectory. It will serve until 1793 (see below) as the residence for the first five Rectors.
1692 The last recorded Dissenting minister, a Rev. Jeremy Hobart, leaves the area “by reason of the numbers of the people turning Quakers and many others being so irreligious that they would do nothing in support of the Gospel.” The town appeals to the colonial governor for help to no avail. The effort to find another minister fails, the position is left vacant, and the parsonage unoccupied.
1693 Benjamin Fletcher, Colonial Governor of New York (1692–1697), and the Colonial Assembly pass the Ministry Act establishing the Church of England in the Colony of New York, under the ecclesiastical authority of the Bishop of London. The Act establishes six parishes and appropriates monies to fund a minister for each. Hempstead is identified as one of the parishes, with boundaries embracing all of “Queens County East of Jamaica.” On a modern map this would encompass all of Nassau County and most of Outer Queens, including the Rockaways. These are the original boundaries of St. George’s parish.
Despite the Minsitry Act, no action is taken to secure ministers to serve the six parishes, so the Act has no real practical effect for several years until petitions are sent from the parishes, including Hempstead, to the Bishop of London requesting ministers and additional financial support.
1694/5 William Vesey, a Dissenting missionary, is reported to be “officiating in Hempstead” before he is ordained and apparently without authorization. Nothing is known about these services. Vesey goes on to be ordained in the Church of England, and in 1698 he becomes the 1st rector of Trinity Church in New York City (now Trinity Wall Street).
St. George’s Begins, 1701–1735
1701 The Society for the Propagation of the Gospel in Foreign Parts (SPG) is founded. It’s three stated goals in North American include “the care and instruction of our own people, settled in the Colonies [i.e., members of the Church of England]; the conversion of the Indian savages, and the conversion of the Negroes.”
1702 The SPG sends George Keith to the colonies of New Jersey and New York to support the existing Church of England congregations and assess the possibility of planting more. Keith arrives in Hempstead in September to find no settled minister in office and the parsonage unoccupied. He begins holding services in the Town meeting house and reports that there was “such a multitude of people, that the church could not hold them, so that many stood without at the doors and windows to hear,” and that they “greatly desired that a Church of England ministry should be settled among them.” Over the next two years, Keith makes several visits to Hempstead to preach and administer the sacraments in support of the nascent congregation. St. George’s dates its founding to Keith’s missionary work.
At the urging of both Vesey and Keith, et al, and with a serviceable building and parsonage readily available, the SPG selects Hempstead to be supplied with a minister.
1703 As a result of the efforts of Keith, a warden and four vestrymen are chosen at a Town meeting. The election of wardens and vestrymen by the town is required by the Ministry Act (see 1693 above), but as noted earlier, the provisions of the Ministry Act, at least on Long Island, were primarily academic until effectuated by the work of the SPG.
1704 With the support Lord Cornbury, the Colonial Governor of New York and New Jersey (1702–1708), John Thomas, assistant minister at Christ Church Philadelphia and director of the parish school, is chosen by the SPG to serve the fledgling Hempstead parish. He is a deacon at the time and leaves for London to be ordained. Upon his return in late 1704, he takes up residence as the 1st Rector serving not only St. George’s but also a smaller congregation in Oyster Bay (now Christ Church Oyster Bay), also started by George Keith. Thomas lives in the abandoned parsonage, which is repaired the following year by order of Lord Cornbury.
1704+ Early church records and correspondence with the SPG show that, in accordance with the goals of the SPG in North America (see 1701 above), children born to enslaved people were baptized at St. George’s and that adult “negro communicants” were catechized and admitted to Holy Communion. Records also show that the first three rectors were themselves slave owners.
1706 Her Majesty Queen Anne (r. 1702–1714) through the SPG provides a Bible, Book of Common Prayer, The Book of Homilies, a silver chalice and paten, and cloths for the pulpit and Communion Table to several congregations in the Colonies of New Jersey and New York. These arrive in 1710. The linens and cloths, Bible, and Book of Homilies have been lost, but the Book of Common Prayer (dated 1710) and the chalice and paten remain in the possession of the parish. For nearly 120 years, until 1830, the “Queen Anne” serves as the only communion set and is still used in the parish on Principal Feasts and major occasions.
1707 In a letter to the SPG, Thomas laments the fact that he has no book in which to record baptisms, marriages, etc., and no monies to purchase one, citing the poverty of his parish. Unfortunately, that registry book never materialized. He is allowed to record some information in the official town records, but only for the five-year period between 1707–1712. Records of official acts from Thomas’ 20-year tenure are largely found in his correspondence with the SPG and noted in SPG reports but these are always in summary form with no names or exact dates, e.g., “Mr. Thomas, within eighteen months, has baptized at least one hundred and sixty, many of whom are adults.” Regular record keeping begins in 1725/6 under the 2nd Rector, Robert Jenny (see below), but primarily baptisms and marriages. Records of burials and funeral are sporadic until 1800.
1710 A marble baptismal font is added to the meeting house. It is moved into the first dedicated church building in 1735, then into the current building in 1822 (see below), where it now resides in the north transept and is used for all baptisms.
1713 At the urgent request of Thomas, the SPG establishes and funds a school associated with the parish “to teach the poorer children reading, writing, and the rudiments of arithmetic.” The SPG appoints parishioner Thomas Gildersleeve to serve as catechist and schoolmaster and provides paper, lesson books, catechisms, and copies of the Book of Common Prayer.
1724 John Thomas dies in office after twenty years of service. His grave is the first recorded burial in the church graveyard, although the exact location is unknown. It is most likely in the oldest section of the graveyard, which is in front of and to the west of Regan Hall. The rectorship is vacant for two years.
1726 The SPG transfers Robert Jenney at his request from his position as missionary to the congregation in Rye, NY (now Christ Church Rye), to St. George’s to become the 2nd Rector. Like his predecessor, Jenney had served as the assistant minister and headmaster of the school at Christ Church Philadelphia.
1734 The meeting house/church (1673), parsonage (1682), and surrounding land and glebe are granted by the Town of Hempstead to St. George’s. The meeting house is torn down, and construction of the first dedicated church building begins, slightly east of the old meeting house on the land now occupied by the current church building (see 1822 below). These two moves enable the congregation, with the support of the colonial governor, the SPG, and the Bishop of London, to petition His Majesty King George II (r. 1727–1760) for a Royal Charter.
The Royal Charter and the First Dedicated Church Building, 1735–1776
1735 His Majesty King George II grants a Royal Charter to St. George’s, the first parish on Long Island and only the third overall to receive a Royal Charter. The Charter legally establishes the parish and gives the congregation control over its own affairs, principally the election of wardens and vestrymen. The primary financial support of the parish remains public funds through the Ministry Act (see 1693 above), and secondarily, the SPG and parishioners.
The new church building is dedicated and named on St. George’s Day, April 23. The service is attended by a host of dignitaries including the Colonial Governor, William Cosby. Several gifts were presented to the parish on this occasion. Those still in the possession of the parish include a silver baptismal bowl from John March of Jamaica (not Queens); and a large wooden coat of arms of George II, painted and gilt, from Governor Cosby. The coat of arms now hangs on the facing of the gallery (choir loft) directly opposite the chancel. Before its dedication to St. George, the Church was apparently referred to as simply Hempstead Church.
An official signed copy of the Royal Charter was also presented. It remained in the possession of the parish until the late 1970s or early 1980s when it was transferred to the New York Historical Society (see below).
Less than two months after the dedication, the steeple is struck by lightning with considerable damage. The “golden cock” weathervane atop the steeple is undamaged, however. (see 1776 below).
1738 Jenney’s wife Sarah dies and is buried in the graveyard. Hers is the earliest extant marker.
1742 Robert Jenney resigns after sixteen years of service to become the Rector of Christ Church Philadelphia. The Vestry calls Samuel Seabury as its 3rd Rector. Seabury is serving St. James’ Church in New London, CT, also an SPG congregation. The Royal Charter gives the authority of electing rectors to the Vestry; however, the SPG must still approve the transfer and the appointment ratified by the Colonial Governor, George Clarke (1736–1743).
1743 Seabury begins his service in February, and the parsonage, now called the Rectory, undergoes much needed repairs, paid for by parishioners. Among the family members Seabury brings to the parish is his 14-year-old son, Samuel Seabury [Jr.], who will become Bishop of Connecticut and, famously, the first Bishop of The Episcopal Church (1784). St. George’s proudly considers him a Bishop Son of the parish.
1744 St. George’s establishes a congregation in Huntington (now St. John’s Huntington). The new congregation, along with the congregation in Oyster Bay, remains under the authority of St. George’s through the Revolutionary War.
1748 The congregation in Huntington builds its own building and requests that Samuel Seabury [Jr.], who has worked at St. George’s since arriving with his father and has been studying under him, be assigned by the SPG as catechist to the congregation.
1750 The congregation in Oyster Bay builds its own building. St. George’s contributes financially to the effort.
1750s At the request of the SPG, Seabury takes several small congregations in Duchess County under his pastoral care, travelling there as often as he can. Seabury also visits congregations in Westchester County during his tenure.
1750s Seabury finds the financial support from the congregation, the SPG, and the Ministry Act (see 1693 above) inadequate to support his expanding family, so he builds a schoolhouse in the rear of the Rectory and takes on private students. The school runs until his death in 1764 and is well regarded and patronized by prominent families in New York and Queens County.
1753 A gallery is added to St. George’s to accommodate the growing congregation. It is paid for by subscription from the parishioners.
1763 More land is ceded to St. George’s by the Town of Hempstead so that the graveyard can be enlarged to the east.
1764 Seabury dies in office after 22 years of service and is buried in the graveyard. St. George’s provides for Seabury’s widow, Elizabeth, by purchasing a plot of land and building her a house. She lives until 1799 and is buried next to husband. The rectorship is vacant for two years.
1766 The Vestry calls Leonard Cutting as the 4th Rector, and the SPG approves his transfer from Christ Church New Brunswick, NJ, to St. George’s. Samuel Seabury [Jr.], now ordained and serving as rector of Grace Church in Queens County (now Grace Church Jamaica), is instrumental in the appointment of Cutting. He continues serving the congregations in Oyster Bay and Huntington until travel becomes dangerous during the Revolutionary War.
The Revolutionary War and Its Aftermath, 1776–1822
1776 Sometime in the late winter or early spring and with war looming, Cutting takes the Queen Anne communion set, colonial silver, books, coat of arms, and Royal Charter to the Rectory for safekeeping.
About May, St. George’s is commandeered by the Continental Army, who are on Long Island looking for “Tories” and “Loyalists.” Services are forbidden, the Church is used as a store house, and the Communion Table used for the “Yankees to eat upon.” Services resume in late August when British troops arrive. After their victory at the Battle of Long Island, a.k.a., The Battle of Brooklyn, the British establish a headquarters in Hempstead. The Communion Table remains in the possession of the parish and now serves as the altar in the Lady Chapel, in the south transept.
Local legend and parish oral history holds that Hessian soldiers used the “Golden Cock” weathervane atop the church tower for target practice. This fact is not mentioned in the first two parish histories (see 1841 and 1881 below) but is mentioned in the third parish history (see 1932 below) and in the 250th Anniversary Celebration program booklet. The weathervane stood atop the spire for nearly 250 years, on both the first and current buildings, before it was stolen in 1982. When it was recovered, about a year later, it did indeed have dents in it consistent with musket ball shot; however, it is impossible to determine who did the shooting. The weathervane was returned to its place on the spire where it remains today. A children’s story entitled “The Golden Cock” dramatizing the story was written c1915 by Carolyn Dale Snedeker, the wife of Charles Snedeker, the 14th Rector.
1784 At the conclusion of the Revolutionary War, after seventeen years of service, Leonard Cutting leaves the parish somewhat abruptly, without officially resigning and becomes known as the “Tory Rector.” Several prominent families who have remained loyal to Britain, leave the parish and move to Canada.
St. George’s is now severed from the financial support of the Ministry Act and the SPG and struggles over the next several years. The congregations in Oyster Bay and Huntington are left to their own devices, although still part of St. George’s parish. They also struggle to survive.
1785 The vestry is unsure how to proceed in choosing a new rector. There are questions as to whether the Royal Charter will be valid under the newly forming state and federal governments and indeed whether it should be honored at all, and the formation of the Episcopal Church is still in its early stages and not yet established. The Vestry’s solution is to have the entire congregation elect the new rector, the only time in the history of St. George’s that this has taken place. Thomas Lambert Moore is elected the 5th Rector. It is believed that Moore’s institution is the first in what will become The Episcopal Church.
The first ordination of a priest in the State of New York (and indeed anywhere outside of Connecticut) takes place at St. George’s, conducted by Samuel Seabury, Bishop of Connecticut, and son of Samuel Seabury [Sr.], the 3rd Rector. (See above).
1787 St. George’s joins the Episcopal of Diocese of New York at its founding, under Bishop Samuel Provoost.
The first Confirmation takes place. One hundred and fifty-five candidates are confirmed by Bishop Provoost.
1789 St. George’s joins the newly established Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States of America at its founding.
1793 The second and current Rectory is built on the same location as the previous parsonage, according to plans by architect and parishioner Timothy Clowes. The Rectory remains the oldest building of the parish and the oldest continuously occupied residence in Nassau County. The design includes slaves/servants quarters over the kitchen. It is not clear if slave labor was used in its construction.
1799 Thomas Moore dies in office after fourteen years of service and is buried under the chancel. A memorial stone tablet is placed in the church in his honor in 1807. When the second dedicated building is built in 1822 (see below), his body is exhumed and re-buried in the graveyard. The memorial tablet is moved into the second church, then placed within the north wall of the recessed chancel in 1856 (see below), where it remains today. The rectorship is vacant for a year.
1799/1800 The vestry issues a call to John Henry Hobart in 1799 to serve as the 6th Rector. Hobart readily accepts the call but is not free to take up residence until the following year because of a temporary commitment in New Brunswick, NJ. He does, however, officiate at St. George’s at least ten times during the interim. He officially begins his service on June 1, 1800. Less than six months later, he is called to be the Assistant Minister at Trinity Church (now Trinity Wall Street) in New York. Subsequently, he is elected Rector of Trinity and Bishop of New York and becomes one of the most important and influential figures in the early history of The Episcopal Church. St. George’s proudly considers him a Bishop Son of the parish.
1800 Seth Hart is elected the 7th Rector.
1802/3 St. George’s establishes a congregation in Manhasset (now Christ Church Manhasset). It remains under the authority of St. George’s until it becomes an independent parish in 1819.
The Second Dedicated Church Building and Gradual Expansion, 1822–1952
1822/3 The first dedicated church building is torn down and the second and current one erected, according to plans by parishioner and architect Timothy Clowes, who also designed the Rectory (see 1793 above). The new building is located on the same plot as the previous one, and the congregation worships at the local Presbyterian church in the interim.
1823 The new church is consecrated on September 19, 1823, by John Henry Hobart, Bishop of New York, who had briefly served St. George’s as the 6th Rector (see 17
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.